Resealed figure discovery debate - G.Kurtz Palitoy VC Jawa.

Star Wars Forum UK - British Fan Community for Toys, Movies & Collecting

Help Support Star Wars Forum UK:

Maulster79 said:
I think 45a TFP are clear.

I think TFP 45b are of great concern.

Need to check lists of high grades and quantities.

I think 45a should be good for most characters, there may be a few but nowhere near the quantities as the others.

As another update there is a clear difference between the seal on an 03 bubble on a Pal or GM45 and a dimpled bubble.

The 03 bubbles do have a 'waffle' seal but its not as tight a waffle as a typical Kenner bubble - I'll try and get some pics up

The dimpled bubble has no waffling at all and I am now convinced that my Bossk is good (slight price sticker residue like the Han) but very unsure about the Stormtrooper.

It would be very useful to start a separate thread with close up bubble photos of GM and Pal 45s
 
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg
 
batman said:
I did a simple experiment to see if i could seal part of a blister to a german cardback using materials that were available in the early 90's and this is the result
I've discussed the details of the experiment and how to use it to seal full blisters with Joe_o and i think it's safe to say for now myth plausible .

As I told you in PM, it could be possible and the outcome is spot on, although this would still would lack the pressure points as discussed by others). This now opens a new can of worms as the repro guys will most likely be watching this thread as well and now have a new process. :shock:


I still do not 100% believe joiner for my own reasons on this........but I will keep those reserved. :wink:
 
spoons said:
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg


er ive got news for you mate, ive had waffled bubble figures off toni, there was at least a few in what i bought as i bought one of each gm card as well as a few palitoy tie pilots and fetts.
 
tiefighterboy said:
batman said:
I did a simple experiment to see if i could seal part of a blister to a german cardback using materials that were available in the early 90's and this is the result
I've discussed the details of the experiment and how to use it to seal full blisters with Joe_o and i think it's safe to say for now myth plausible .

As I told you in PM, it could be possible and the outcome is spot on, although this would still would lack the pressure points as discussed by others). This now opens a new can of worms as the repro guys will most likely be watching this thread as well and now have a new process. :shock:


I still do not 100% believe joiner for my own reasons on this........but I will keep those reserved. :wink:

That's the reason i haven't mentioned the fresh unicorn milk and magic wand you would need to do this trick. Move along now scammers, this is not the post you are looking for :lol:
 
I think we need to focus on Joiner's shady past and ask questions about that. His ramblings take the heat off of him and make us focus on Toni. When you ask him about the things he has done...............he manipulates it to somehow turn back to this issue...which he acts like it was nothing....he plays stupid...but he damn well knows this was going to cause a **** storm. It all works to his advantage by bringing him back into the community and throwing the hounds on another dealer. Just an observation.
 
TOYTONI said:
Thats correct they came from Arthur Bailie he bought around 25,000 figures bubbles and cards i was in on the deal and tried to buy the lot of Arthur but lost out to Toni , i think Toni bought them for around £10K , i know at one point Arthur was trying to buy figures as he had cards but no figures to put on them , what i really wanted was a set of the cards unused for myself but that never happened, i used to see Toni place ads in model mart though out the 90s and early 2000s selling these figures, he said to me once that he had found a way t heat the bubbles and attach them to the cards in the same way they did at the factory i think he may have even gone to a factory to have them put on the cards, i have never really gone for these German cards as i felt they were not relay finished figures, somewhere have a complete brake down of all the cards , there was also around 2000 carded figures that came in at the same time as Arthur bought the cards , i bought 500 carded hoth troopers on ROTJ cards and also around 700 Boba fett figures on ROTJ cards also , i sold the 700 to Crage Steven's a collator in Romford who when he got them opened them all that was around 1988 ish i think ? anyway there you go some more history


Several friends have contacted me regarding a post by a certain Jason Joiner and having read his "story" I feel its necessary to reply.
This story is mainly fantasy with a few facts thrown in.
As a one time major dealer and expert in Star Wars it is bizarre that after some 25 years Mr Joiner should now come up with this "information" out of the blue!
I have been dealing in many different types of vintage toys for over 30 years including Star Wars for about 25 years . Ive been on Ebay since 1998 and have had 2 websites Toytoni and Zoomertoys running for the last 16 years. I have not seen or had any communication with Mr Joiner for the best of 20 years nor have I heard of him making such comments elsewhere.
I did indeed buy various toys from a dealer called Arthur in the 80s and early 90s these included tin toys , robots, TV related and carded Star Wars figures. He had a reputation for getting old stock and had good contacts in the regular toy trade. He was one of several dealers that I bought carded Star Wars from. He seemed a nice guy who seemed always short of cash and often offered items which he didn't exactly have but could get his hands on if he could make the sale in advance .So at times it wasn't clear if he actually had the goods or just new a man who had them .
I do remember there indeed was a list of items which included unused cards but these never materialised I never saw any or was offered any samples from him . I ended up buying quite large quantities of carded figures from him which were a mix of Kenner ,POTF,Palitoy.,german General Mills and Trilogo non of which came in trade boxes - in those days there wasn't that much interest in carded figures let alone in the outer boxes.
The fact that there was this list stirred up some gossip at the time about unused cards but as to whether they existed is unknown. Mr Joiner claims there were many thousands and yet he couldn't get his hands on a single example from this Arthur dealer despite buying 500 carded Hothtroopers ? and a staggering 700 carded Fetts???- what utter nonsense !He claims the Fetts were then mysteriously taken off the cards - why would someone cut up 700 carded Fetts - more nonsense- we really are in the realms of fantasy here . What happened to the 500 carded hothtroopers? Where are these 1000s of factory cards? Mr Joiners assertions that I was claiming I was going to some factory to get bubbles sealed is total fantasy .
Arthur on several occasions told me that he thoroughly disliked Mr Joiner ( as did many others- normally mild mannered guys threatening him with physical violence on several occasions at toyfairs ) so its highly unlikely that he exactly would confide in him about the details of what he had, what he kept and who he sold what to who.
I suppose it is possible that he had been offered unused cards or even had some but I have completely lost touch with Arthur since he went on to other things and have had no contact with him for over 10 years.
I hope this clarifies things if any one has any general questions Im happy to reply but please dont expect me to remember details of exactly who did or said what over 20 years ago!.
Toni

PS
As far as the seal on the General Mills and Palitoys- its generally accepted that most Palitoy Esb and Rotj have smooth seals as do the German issues which were made in the UK .
As far as ESB style bubbles on ROTJ cards is concerned this is also not that unusual although rectangular bubbles are the norm ESB style bubbles were used on ROTJ cards both Palitoy/German and Kenner .I hope that clarifies those points .
 
David Tree said:
heh, I did say how you do it back on page 51, but no-one responded to it, it's ok folk, I'm used to it, I'll just go off now and cry to myself ;)


Dave

Hi David, i've read your post and the funny thing is i was at work doing my experiment at almost the same moment you were writing your post. I just thought it would not be a good idea to post a full write up of the process on a public forum so i went with the pictures instead.Thanks for not mentioning the "special ingredients" involved for doing this trick :wink:
 
What about all the Clipper moc's tony are selling ? Almost all of them are mint and there are alot floting around ... I use to own this one ... Did not get it from Tony and can't remember who i sold it to .

th_bmxdele017.jpg


Here are a close up ... i took it becouse i wanted to make a post about wbg beards :-)

th_wbgsale005.jpg
 
I understand your concerns over jason Todd but it doesn't change much that has come to light in this thread about Toni.
 
Caswellbot said:
I understand your concerns over jason Todd but it doesn't change much that has come to light in this thread about Toni.

I know and a lot of the facts coming out about Toni are interesting. I was just looking at Joiner's posts and thought...If I had a bad rep.....would it not be easy to fabricate a story and put the heat elsewhere.
 
jb1 said:
spoons said:
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg


er ive got news for you mate, ive had waffled bubble figures off toni, there was at least a few in what i bought as i bought one of each gm card as well as a few palitoy tie pilots and fetts.

Oh well back to the drawing board :lol:

Are they all 03 bubbles?

For what it's worth I'd happily buy a GM card with an 03 bubble and waffle seal even it is was from Toni

If Toni is sealing figures with random bubbles the chances of him deliberately matching the waffle seal to the 03 bubble seem slim.

if the dimpled bubbles prove to be just a bubble variation (unlikely considering the dimples appear on different types) then i dont know what to think

This really could all be JJ **** stirring but my gut feeling is that GM cards would all be sealed at the same factory with the same bubbles - single stem

The production run can't have been that long?

I won't even think about Palitoy 45c cards
 
It woud indeed Todd but as we can see from the posts it doesnt seem a fabrication. You are not te only one tha wants to quiz Jason by the looks of it but all in good time. I don't know if anyones brains could take another similar thread starting up right now. We may have to rename the forum SWFBI. :lol:
 
Andy raises a good point about the length of production run. Doesn't there seem to be a lot of bubble/ fig combos on the cards being discussed? That seems a bit odd to me .
 
jb1 said:
spoons said:
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg


er ive got news for you mate, ive had waffled bubble figures off toni, there was at least a few in what i bought as i bought one of each gm card as well as a few palitoy tie pilots and fetts.

Have you got any pics Jim?
 
spoons said:
jb1 said:
spoons said:
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg


er ive got news for you mate, ive had waffled bubble figures off toni, there was at least a few in what i bought as i bought one of each gm card as well as a few palitoy tie pilots and fetts.

Oh well back to the drawing board :lol:

Are they all 03 bubbles?

For what it's worth I'd happily buy a GM card with an 03 bubble and waffle seal even it is was from Toni

If Toni is sealing figures with random bubbles the chances of him deliberately matching the waffle seal to the 03 bubble seem slim.

if the dimpled bubbles prove to be just a bubble variation (unlikely considering the dimples appear on different types) then i dont know what to think

This really could all be JJ **** stirring but my gut feeling is that GM cards would all be sealed at the same factory with the same bubbles - single stem

The production run can't have been that long?

I won't even think about Palitoy 45c cards


they wasnt all waffled seals on the mocs no sorry, the smooth seals in question could well have been done at the palitoy factory as most palitoy seals seem to be smooth, could they have been sent in loose form to palitoy to be sealed with whatever figures they had and never had the palitoy offer sticker applied which has been seen on other non toni gm mocs? just thought id throw that one in there just to confuse a little more.
 
Caswellbot said:
jb1 said:
spoons said:
very hard to seal the 'waffle' - there is some roughness around the 03 in the pic but if you own one hold it under a light and the waffling is quite clear

Hopefully no-one now comes forward with 03 bubbles from Toni :roll:

DSC05390_zps83cf9d19.jpg


er ive got news for you mate, ive had waffled bubble figures off toni, there was at least a few in what i bought as i bought one of each gm card as well as a few palitoy tie pilots and fetts.

Have you got any pics Jim?

actually i think i may have yes, im not sure if theyre group shots though which wouldnt really help but ill have a look as i may still have the shots from when i sold them all on ebay. you may have to give me a couple of days though :roll:
 
right ive found the photobucket folder with them all in but i dont know if they will be of any use so heres three, the backs are first on each, if theyre any good i have a LOT more.

100_2492.jpg

100_2491.jpg

100_2490.jpg

100_2489.jpg

100_2488.jpg

100_2487.jpg
 
ive also noticed that the flecking that you can get with gm mocs has not affected behind the seal or bubble, is this possibly because they was sealed many years ago? im not really qualified to answer that one. but if it does, then that adds creadence to the fact that they wasnt done yesterday.
 
Going back to my earlier point I have evidence for waffle sealed GM shop sold stock, so I'd be more dubious about smooth sealed ESB GM stock

For any ROTJ cards all bets are off

If you have German or uk ESB 45 backs with a loose waffle seal with an 03 bubble then I'd bet that they were legit. I'd may even be tempted to make a Joe Y style statement about being willing to buy them

£50 each ;)

Edit - just seen Jim's pics, I reckon the Han and Bossk are good if there is a loose waffle

They even have the same bow to them as my stickered one

Can't speak for Yoda but its been on the card for a while
 
Thanks Jim I can defo see the 03 on the bossk bubble and a think i can make it out on han hoth too. A little to tricky to see it on the yoda though.
 
I don't think there was on that one mate, but I remember getting it back from the graders as Carlos75 bought one at the same time which had a brown snake, (i infact sent it with my own afa sub) his also had the same flecking and like mine got really low card grades. I distinctly remember being pissed at the fact it got such grades but also the fact that the flecking didn't extend under the seal or bubble. Leading me to think they may have not being kept in good order by Toni as other cards also had it but not nearly so bad.
 
Caswellbot said:
Thanks Jim I can defo see the 03 on the bossk bubble and a think i can make it out on han hoth too. A little to tricky to see it on the yoda though.

Very late to the party on this one. I've had quite a few moc off Toni over the years, I defo remember my Bossk had that 03 stamp on the bubble. Annoyingly all my cards are boxed up at my parent's as im moving house.

I do have real concerns about all this, but like others I'm on thefence for now.
Wish I still had my mails from when I was doing a deal with Toni, I recall asking if he had any more GM Leia Hoths as he has sold out on his site. He said he didn't at the mo, but might be able to source some more,never thought anything of it at the time,but now...........
 
I went to collect mine in person, more for the fact that I was handing over nearly 3k. I remember him saying that he had a contact in Germany where he could source more.
 
JESUS... 64 pages later, that was some reading... :o :o

I do think it is odd for someone to have a seemingly unlimited supply of MINT Moc's.

All he has to do is take a photo of his remaining stock to show that they are all already on the card and this could be put to bed.

If he is not willing to do this then I would say he is just making them to order all be it with genuine cards and bubbles.

He does not seem to bothered about the allegations which is very strange.. :? :? :?
 
Just for the record, although I never checked for dimples closely on the top of the bubbles, I often noticed a dimple on the side of the bubble half way down and in the middle if thats any use ?
 
So can anyone explain the lack of flecking behind the seals and bubbles if they are made recently? Obviously ive seen it on quite a few Toni mocs and they're all the same, if there's flecking on the card its not behind the bubbles and seals, that goes for single and double stem bubbles.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top