Donations needed for ESB - Revisisted!!!

Clone Collector

Padawan
Joined
Nov 7, 2009
Messages
184
Hi people, I hope it's OK to post this?? If not please do remove or I shall remove it, and no offence meant.

Not so long back I became aware of a chap called Aidywan on Face Book, this great fellow was so upset with the awful Lucas Film Special Edition revisions that he decided to do his own, and fix just about all of the mistakes, poor editing and general look of all the special effects shots that were not revised.

From this, a few years later, Star Wars A New Hope Revisited was eventually created, an it was everything that Lucas should have done and didn't do with the Special Editions. Dialogue, effects, picture quality, extra scene's were all added and adjusted to create a new vision of a film that we all love, scene's were edited differently to make more sense (see the scene in Obi-Wan's hovel with R2), in short, the whole movie has been wonderfully restored and updated! I am aware that many do not agree with these updates of what is a classical movie but what this guy has done, on his own equipment and own time is astounding, and I regularly watch this version on DVD when not watching Blu ray.

Next in line to be restored is Empire Strikes Back. This time round, the restoration and reworking is to be in Blu ray format. Aidy is nearly done but needs some donations to finish off the last of the movie. The target he has set £1300, £300 has already been collected so the total to raise stands at £1000. Please if you could spare any cash for the donation it will be much appreciated, as from what I have seen of the screen shots from ESB Revisited, it's going to be epic and worth every penny the man puts into it.

Here is the link to the facebook page so you can become familiar with Aidy's work.

http://www.facebook.com/swrevisited

And here is the link if you would be so good as to donate some of your hard earned to enjoy a classical version of Empire! The Donate button is on the right, it's the paypal logo.

http://swrevisited.wordpress.com/

Thanks guys

Steve
 
This is really exciting. Grant is sending me the SW revisited and i can't wait to see it. I am one of those who cannot/will not watch the Lucas 90s reedits. They are awful and completely ruin the films. What i do own and watch are the original unedited versions on DVD but i've long wished that certain parts, effects wise, that are a little lacing in quality, could be cleaned up somehow. Without some cartoon alien being added (what is it with Lucas and cartoon aliens these days??). So these more tactful, careful, stylish, cartoon alien-less reedits are a ****ing god-send. Literally a wish come true for me and to have the entire trilogy done would be incredible!
I for one will be donating for sure. Not this week as i'm skint but i'll chuck £25 in next weekend.
 
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.
 
edd_jedi said:
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.

I agree and with Disney's Legal team...he could get a hard ****ing.
 
as much as i love sw:r and am stoked for empire...I cant get on board with funding this. I'm sure i listened to an interview with guy who is doing this (very talented editor) but he doesnt work, and is claiming sick benefits...I could be wrong and apologise if i am. I cant help but feel that funding this guy isnt a good thing. plus some of the stuff he's added to empire is unnecassary and feels like he's only adding it because he can. additional background hoth troops...pointless and not in keeping with the original goal he set out with on anh, to fix continuity errors and colour correction etc.... out right ****ing around with a damn near perfect film aint cool. oh and if he isnt keeping perfect books to show he isnt taking 1p from what he is given, he's ****ed...disney will come down on him HARD!!!!
 
edd_jedi said:
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.

I assumed it was for costs rather than profit. Could be wrong. Would not donate if it was just lining his pockets. He could land himself in BIG trouble if he's seen to be profiting from this.
 
That's what I mean, I'm not sure what costs there can be apart from time? He's already done ANH so clearly has the kit already.
 
And surely if Disney did go apeshit on him, would who ever is financing it be implicated too??
 
No. There's no danger of that.
If Disney did find out what he was doing, take issue and come after him it would be between him and them. Also, if he's not made any money off it there's very little they can do except issue a 'cease and desist' order and shut him down.
 
PGowdy said:
No. There's no danger of that.
If Disney did find out what he was doing, take issue and come after him it would be between him and them. Also, if he's not made any money off it there's very little they can do except issue a 'cease and desist' order and shut him down.

But that's exactly what I mean by him keeping extremely detailed books to document exactly what he is spending the £1000's that have been donated....This isn't the first tme he's asked for money to complete Empire: revisted!
 
It's not mandatory to donate.

Quite happy to support a good cause.

Prefer to give my money to support talent than 90% of what corporate cinema has released in the last 20 years.
 
Maulster79 said:
Prefer to give my money to support talent than 90% of what corporate cinema has released in the last 20 years.

I heartily agree with that after watching Total Recall 2012 last night. Seriously, how thick are most people these days? Is this what your average bloke wants to watch now? Absolute drivel. I can't watch any film where a 7 stone stunning girl is supposed to be a bad ass.
 
Maulster79 said:
It's to pay for the models etc.. That are to view on the FB page. It's not for profit.

I second that!! :mrgreen: :mrgreen:

edd_jedi said:
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.

My personal opinion is that you should get flamed for that! Sorry, but this guy has invested thousands of hours to give us...yeah us the fans...a version we finally can live with it! What is his profit in cash??? Nothing I can promise you! 1500 will not be more then 1USD per hour! Whom do you know working for that kind of money and whom do you know calling that a profit??? payed work??? Comon...you cant be serious at that...are you???

I guess the software alone has cost him more then that!


I totally understand him asking for at least a bit of money! He invested so many hours of his life to just get nopthing and IMO has done the greatest job on SW "renewing" ever!

This guy is taleneted to the limit! And I better spend my hard earned money for him then going into cinema one more time to see crap movies!! Opinion second like mentioned before!

Sorry for beeing harsh, but it is just my honest opinion!
 
wbobafett said:
Maulster79 said:
It's to pay for the models etc.. That are to view on the FB page. It's not for profit.

I second that!! :mrgreen: :mrgreen:

edd_jedi said:
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.

My personal opinion is that you should get flamed for that! Sorry, but this guy has invested thousands of hours to give us...yeah us the fans...a version we finally can live with it! What is his profit in cash??? Nothing I can promise you! 1500 will not be more then 1USD per hour! Whom do you know working for that kind of money and whom do you know calling that a profit??? payed work??? Comon...you cant be serious at that...are you???

I guess the software alone has cost him more then that!


I totally understand him asking for at least a bit of money! He invested so many hours of his life to just get nopthing and IMO has done the greatest job on SW "renewing" ever!

This guy is taleneted to the limit! And I better spend my hard earned money for him then going into cinema one more time to see crap movies!! Opinion second like mentioned before!

Sorry for beeing harsh, but it is just my honest opinion!
Totally entitled to your opinion.
However my two cents on what Ady is doing with Empire are as follows. As I stated before I love SW:R, I love the colour correction work, the fixing of continuity errors and the tweaking of the effects (what he did with the Cantina Creatures is awesome) But I'm sorry, the outright ****ing around he is doing on Empire is shocking. All that film required after the colour correction **** up that Lucasfilm did on the Special Editions and Blu Ray release was a couple of FX tweaks, I can't actually think of any to be fair right now but there's probably a couple. The adding of additional background characters is ****ing pointless and stinks of a "I'm doing it because I can" attitude. He's just come out and said that he's messing with the At-At's on Hoth to make them look less stop motiony....I'm sorry but WTF!!!! there is nothing wrong with those effects, the stop motiony look adds to the character of those walkers.
I'm all for supporting local filmmakers and genuine Talent (which I believe Ady has) but riding on the back of someone elses talent, Lucas, Kirshner, all the guys at ILM and everyone that made the original films....that I'm not cool with.
You're free to give him your money (I don't think he deserves a penny for all the hours he's put in, his choice his free time) and fair play to you. Oh and as I said before this isn't the first $$$ drive he's done, so it's a bit more than £1500, I think this might actually be the third he's done for Empire.
He didn't ask for a penny when he did SW:R, so why is he asking now for the film that in my opinion required the least amount of "improvement".
Just my opinion on the matter :D
 
wbobafett said:
Maulster79 said:
It's to pay for the models etc.. That are to view on the FB page. It's not for profit.

I second that!! :mrgreen: :mrgreen:

edd_jedi said:
I may get flamed for this, but my opinion is that despite the fact he is obviously putting a lot of time and effort in to it, and I'm as keen to see it as you guys are, he should not be asking for money. I assume what he's doing is borderline illegal anyway, as soon as he starts asking people to pay him to do it, it stops being a passion and becomes paid work, involving copyrighted material.

My personal opinion is that you should get flamed for that! Sorry, but this guy has invested thousands of hours to give us...yeah us the fans...a version we finally can live with it! What is his profit in cash??? Nothing I can promise you! 1500 will not be more then 1USD per hour! Whom do you know working for that kind of money and whom do you know calling that a profit??? payed work??? Comon...you cant be serious at that...are you???

I guess the software alone has cost him more then that!



I totally understand him asking for at least a bit of money! He invested so many hours of his life to just get nopthing and IMO has done the greatest job on SW "renewing" ever!

This guy is taleneted to the limit! And I better spend my hard earned money for him then going into cinema one more time to see crap movies!! Opinion second like mentioned before!

Sorry for beeing harsh, but it is just my honest opinion!

Disagree totally. I've made a donation to cover purchasing models, paying for direct costs etc but not to pay for his time. He is working with someone lse's creation. If I retyped a novel but changed some adjectives would I expect to be paid for it? He should not (and as at as I know doesn't) expect to be paid for his time as a job.

But you flamed Edd which deserves a :lol:
 
Cc4rhu said:
But you flamed Edd which deserves a :lol:

*ducks*... :lol:

I just had a problem with the "becomes payed work" sentence...that is all! It will never become payed work if you ask me!...that was my point..nothing more.
I dont think everyone needs to like his work on ESB and I didnt knew there were already two donations for ESB also....

Last time I read up on the project I liked it very much...but that is a year back or so! :roll: ...seems it is time again to read up....actually I didnt know that he is messing around with the AT-ATs :shock: ...
 
Old Thread: Hello . There have been no replies in this thread for 365 days.
Content in this thread may no longer be relevant.
Perhaps it would be better to start a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom