It's his forum. Enough said! lol
I'll air my thoughts as there is nowhere to do it on RS now..
Joe honestly shouldn't have given the newbie guy such an online ass whooping, he is a veteran of RS and he knows the rules, he is also a well respected (by many but not all) collector and his bootleg collection and his love of bootlegs is enjoyed by a lot of people around the world. In fact he can safely say that the increase of bootleg lovers in recent times is ALL because of him, he does some really amazing sales and his collection is inspiring - he also loves to feed peoples addiction so he wins the title of bootleg lord..so all said and done why waste your time by using a newbie who posted in the wrong section as a baseball and trying to hit a home run with him while things get progressively worse and no one is backing down? It was obvious a lot of the moderators were not around at the time to put a stop to it in its infancy but that isn't a green light to keep going IMO.
Now..lets look at RS, it's known for being pretty "stiff" at the best of times but us Vintage guys (whether you agree or not) for the longest time were allowed to run rampant around the boards screaming and yelling at each other with not much moderation, the odd time Shane turned up and reminded people to continue discussing the topic at hand but honestly if you go back and look at some of the older arguments you can see some pretty bad **** going on in the form of disrespectful rants and name calling.
So..Joe's argument thing happened, everyone gets a wake up call in the form of Joe getting a suspension for a month and with Shane off the team and the arguing Philip probably thinks - I guess these Vintage guys obviously aren't very good at self moderating even when the majority of the members have an average age of 30+..
I am not saying Joe's incident has spoiled it for everyone but honestly since that all went down we have had a severe increase in the moderation levels on RS and Philip (who regardless of your feelings for him can do whatever he wants - its his board) is handing out suspensions/warnings and permanently removing people that say boo to a few geese.
I think the fallout of Joe being banned and a bunch of supporters trying to **** around on RS with bumping old threads of Joe's, opening all those threads about bootlegs etc was a really nice show of appreciation for the guy but its actually turned RS into a pretty shitty place.
Whats worse is that those guys all jumped ship now and ****ed off to another board! So what was the point?
Now you have people pulling limelights left right and center just to hop on the bandwagon and it seems like RS has turned into a soap opera overnight..