Scottish independence

weasel

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
20,284
Location
My Island
Any of our Scottish members any strong feelings on this?

Is it just Cameron trying to help himself out by hiving off 30 odd Labour MP's!? Would Scotland actually vote to leave? Will the wording of the question affect the outcome? What happens about the debts, mainly RBS? And the oil!?
 
I am half Scottish with a pretty Scottish name - Iain Mackenzie, however, in my opinion, if the Scots want independence they can bloody well have it.

For me, in this current climate, this is the last thing that people should be worrying about and to be honest, if it did happen then people in England would be better off (albeit not by a lot)

Public spending per head is higher in Scotland than in England, a fact English nationalists use to make the case that the English are subsidising the Scots and would be wealthier if the union ended.

Scots nationalists say they could cope perfectly well without money from London, if they were able to levy their own taxes and make their own spending decisions, particularly if they were free to keep the revenue from North Sea oil.

North Sea oil

As FactCheck has shown in the past, most of the UK's fossil fuel lies off the coast of Scotland.

"Detailed research of the money brought in by the UK oil and gas fields suggests that Scottish waters - defined by the line of demarcation used in the fishing industry - accounted for 91.1 per cent of UK North Sea revenue in 2008/09," our team found.

But even with this revenue, Scotland has raised less in tax than it has spent since 2005. Official figures show the deficit was £2bn in 2005-06, rising to £14bn in 2009-10 (10.6 per cent of Scottish GDP) as the economy worsened. But Scotland's deficit was lower than the UK's (11.1 per cent of GDP).

Countries don't collapse as a result of constitutional change. Prof David Bell, Stirling University

Professor David Bell, an economist at Stirling University, told Channel 4 News that while public spending was higher in Scotland than in England, England would not experience a gold rush if Scotland went it alone. "It's not a huge sum of money. It's not nirvana by any means at all."
 
My nan is scottish and her feelings are strong on this,big fat NO to going it alone!

My own opinion is let them do what they want as long as we both commit to military co-operation,the scots are hard as **** and we need them in that sense :lol: :lol:

Cannot see it happening though tbh...
 
It's gonna be ****ing complicated if it dopes happen. It'll also open a feckin can of worms over here as well :roll:
 
Labour supporters had better hope it doesn't happen or they can say goodby to getting into power again.
Theres more panda's in scotland than tory mp's!
 
Old Thread: Hello . There have been no replies in this thread for 365 days.
Content in this thread may no longer be relevant.
Perhaps it would be better to start a new thread instead.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom