I really liked it there hasn't been a decent moody space scifi in years , moon and event horizon come to mind. i think had the ship fell and killed the female professor and the film were to end there it would of been fantastic, but the bit at the end where they take off in the ship and we see an alien chestated as we know is revealed ruined it, all to hollywoody! i bet thats how fox studio wanted it, had ridley scott had his way i think the ending would of been better