AFA end loose u-grading

TK-7785

Jedi Master
Joined
Mar 16, 2017
Messages
942
This is excellent news! However, call me suspicious but will this actually stop the opening of sealed items? The wording is somewhat ambiguous in this regard.

If someone is chasing a 90 grade I assume they can still request a MOC is opened in the hopes of getting a 90? AFA would more than likely oblige. I'd like to hear confirmation that AFA will stop opening original sealed items regardless of what arbitrary letter and number combination they assign.

Chris
 

AllThings80s

Youngling
Joined
Mar 2, 2017
Messages
17
It should never have been on the menu with any of these companies to begin with. I wonder how many thousands of MOC's perished during this barbaric time? And yet people still give them their money :roll:
 

TheJabbaWookie

Sith Lord
Joined
Jun 28, 2017
Messages
2,740
Location
Somewhere Down The Rabbit Hole
TK-7785 said:
This is excellent news! However, call me suspicious but will this actually stop the opening of sealed items? The wording is somewhat ambiguous in this regard.

If someone is chasing a 90 grade I assume they can still request a MOC is opened in the hopes of getting a 90? AFA would more than likely oblige. I'd like to hear confirmation that AFA will stop opening original sealed items regardless of what arbitrary letter and number combination they assign.

Chris
Even if AFA don't u grade people will still open them themselves and submit in the hope of obtaining a 90 Gold as the premium people are willing to pay for those is astonishing. Still I agree it's a welcome statement long overdue.
 

Palifan

Sith Lord
Joined
Oct 28, 2012
Messages
4,902
The U grade should have never happened in the first place but there's no point thinking about that now as what's done is done and I'm sure the people who never agreed with this probably boycotted AFA years ago. It's a positive announcement though for the future and will help AFA's rep in the longterm I'm sure (for some anyway).

As for people opening items to send in anyway, there's nothing that can be done about that and people won't really know. I'm sure that practise has been going on for years anyway as I wouldn't be surprised if there's more value in an AFA 90 up against an AFA U 90 (that thought is based on nothing though :lol: ). I still think it's a win for us all and will probably drive a few U collectors up the wall who are trying to complete a whole run.

Ian
 

stu70

Padawan
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
241
Location
UK
Staggering that it's taken them this long to stop doing it, love the quote,

"We have finished compiling the results of the multiple surveys we've conducted over the past year "

They needed multiple surveys to work out that destroying MOC's was wrong! :shock:
 

Frunkstar

Grand Master
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
5,653
Location
North Wales - Beyond The Outer Rim!
My first thoughts were also does this actually mean they are going to stop opening sealed items, if that is indeed the case it's a huge win for the hobby as a whole, if not then this is a hollow gesture, I am keeping my fingers crossed it is the former.

I am sure this announcement will delight the like of Mr Mullan & Mr Jacobs etc etc, about time they had the rug pulled from under their feet & with luck it may mean we start seeing more damaged cards / cut bubbles & so on at fairer prices for those who collect on a budget like myself.

Good buy the serial U grader - hurrah hurrah!
 

Darth Bobby

Sith Lord
Supporter
Joined
Sep 18, 2015
Messages
1,177
Does anyone have an estimate of how many items have been U graded over the years? The damage is already done? They probably only stopped doing it as it's not fashionable.
 

weasel

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
19,847
Location
My Island
Survival kit Chris said:
Means nothing , the damage is done .

Yeap, you beat me to it.
I'm not actively buying any more but the sheer number of MOC's that have been destoryed over the last few years as people chase U grades, or send in "beaters" to get a U grade and double the price they can sell for, is staggering. I would say a tangible percentage of the MOC's around before U grading came along have now been destroyed. Those can never be replaced. Never.
I do accept some would have been opened by people or destroyed by mishaps/lost in the post etc. but AFA have been responsible for a huge increase in the destruction.
When I started collecting way back when, MOC's were fairly common on eBay. If you wanted to collect a set and weren't too fussy on condition you could probably have done it without too much effort. The numbers available now are a fraction of that.
Partly it's people moving away from eBay, but mainly it's because so many of those MOC's were destroyed so people could get a few extra quid. AFA are entirely to blame for facilitaing the greed.

And them no longer U grading won't stop people sending in MOC's. If AFA refuse to open them, people will just open them and send the figure in themselves. AFA have open the tin of worms. There's nothing can be done to repair the damage.
 

batman

Padawan
Joined
Jun 1, 2011
Messages
96
As far as I can tell they don't refuse to open them , they just don't put the U on the label anymore :
" We have finished compiling the results of the multiple surveys we've conducted over the past year and as a result will no longer assign the 'U' or "Uncirculated" designation for loose vintage toys. This change will go into effect for submissions received after the end of the current month."
It would have been nice if they had realized it is destructive to the collectable to open it but it seems like they just realised It affects their appeal to customers in a negative way to be associated with the term U grading .
 

Frunkstar

Grand Master
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
5,653
Location
North Wales - Beyond The Outer Rim!
mr_palitoy said:
AFA have confirmed they won't be opening stuff going forwards.

Jason

& that has to be a good thing I know, but I have to say I am totally with weasel on this, his post pretty much sums up exactly how I feel,well put weaz!, sadly all those MOC & Baggies can never be put back to the way they were & it makes my flesh creep just considering what wonders in terms of unknown baggie types we will never have the chance to see or document which have been lost to these greedy bastards, they knew full well it was a destructive practice & did not give a rats ass, it was & still is sadly all about the mighty dollar, IMO the only reason it has been halted is due to the likes of UKG & CSA upping standards & them feeling the pain in their coffers.

As weaz said there was a time not so long ago if you wanted to put a run together whatever it was (within reason) that was achievable without breaking the bank, that ship has long since sailed & much of it is down to this sheer stupidity.
 

edd_jedi

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
8,877
Location
UK
Definitely good news for the future, just a shame that so many thousands of MOCs, baggies and sealed shipping cases were sacrificed to get here.
 

Stuart Skinner

Sith Lord
Joined
Apr 29, 2013
Messages
3,165
Definitely feels like all too little too late.

Yes it's excellent news that they've finally decided to take this decision but after year upon year of ugrading the damage has well and truly be done. Them saying about looking at the campaign to stop it, the Ugrade party that marched on AFA at Celebration in Anaheim and presented them with their petition was back in 2015 and they've only just taken this course of action.

Maybe sceptical but I wonder whether this decision is being taken with maybe the fact that they no longer get many people requesting ugrades so by banning the procedure gives them good publicity across many forums and facebook groups whilst not affecting their profits. If Ugrading was at it's peak I doubt they would be taking this decision.

Like I say great decision but way too late to get any pat on the back from me.
 

Mini99

Sith Lord
Supporter
Joined
Sep 1, 2016
Messages
4,755
Maybe sceptical but I wonder whether this decision is being taken with maybe the fact that they no longer get many people requesting ugrades so by banning the procedure gives them good publicity across many forums and facebook groups whilst not affecting their profits. If Ugrading was at it's peak I doubt they would be taking this decision.
The answer of a cynic, :wink: but I truly believe you are 100% correct!
It's just about making as much noise as possible to make them look like a caring and consensus company, which they obviously aren't.
 
Old Thread: Hello . There have been no replies in this thread for 365 days.
Content in this thread may no longer be relevant.
Perhaps it would be better to start a new thread instead.

Latest posts

Top Bottom